Design-Bid-Build vs Design-Build vs CM at Risk
By Wyatt Cooper · Published · 4 min read
Key takeaways
- Design-bid-build: two contracts, design first, and the price fixed by bid on finished drawings.
- Design-build: one contract for design and construction, with the price set early (best value) or as the design develops (progressive).
- CM at risk: two contracts, the builder hired during design, and a guaranteed maximum price set before construction.
Design-bid-build, design-build and construction manager at risk differ in how many contracts the owner signs and when price is fixed. Design-bid-build has separate design and construction contracts, priced by bid on finished drawings. Design-build is one contract for both. CM at risk keeps two contracts but hires the builder during design and fixes a guaranteed maximum price before construction.
The three methods side by side
| Design-bid-build | Design-build | CM at risk | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contracts the owner holds | Two: designer, and contractor | One: the design-builder | Two: designer, and construction manager |
| When the builder joins | After design is complete | At the start, with the designer on its team | During design |
| How the builder is chosen | Usually low bid | Qualifications, then a best-value proposal, or qualifications alone (progressive) | Qualifications and fee |
| When the price is fixed | At bid, on finished drawings | At award (best value) or once design is far enough along (progressive) | When the GMP is agreed, before construction |
| Who usually answers for design errors (check your contract) | The owner, to the contractor | The design-builder | The owner, to the CM |
| Best for | Well-defined work where cost certainty at bid matters most | Speed and one point of responsibility | Complex work that benefits from the builder's input during design |
What each source says
The Construction Management Association of America's owner's guide says design-bid-build "usually leads to the sealed bid, fixed price contract" and describes CM at risk as the construction manager acting "as consultant to the owner in the development and design phases, but as the equivalent of a general contractor during the construction phase". The Design-Build Institute of America (what is design-build) calls "the single contract for both design and construction" the fundamental difference.
Federal rules show how each is bought. Two-phase design-build (FAR subpart 36.3) rates qualifications without price in phase one, then takes priced proposals from generally no more than five firms. GSA's construction manager as constructor (GSAM subpart 536.71) buys design-phase services at a fixed price with an option for construction at a guaranteed maximum price.
An example: one clinic, three timelines
Take a made-up clinic with 8 months of design and 12 of construction. Under design-bid-build, add a month to bid and award: 21 months, price known at month 9. Under CM at risk, the builder joins at month 2, the GMP is set at month 7, and early packages can start before design ends, so the price is known two months sooner. Under design-build the owner signs one contract at month 0. Overlap shortens the job only when the work allows it, so ask each firm for its own schedule.
Whichever you choose, select the builder with written criteria (how to choose a general contractor) and level priced proposals the same way (how to compare contractor proposals).
The bottom line
Pick the method by what you need most: cost certainty on a finished design (design-bid-build), one point of responsibility and speed (design-build), or the builder's input during design with a capped price (CM at risk).
Conflo puts the owner, the contractor and the subs on the same job under any of the three. Join the waitlist to try it.
Sources
- An Owner's Guide to Construction and Program Management (2011) — Construction Management Association of America. Read October 16, 2026.
- What is design-build? — Design-Build Institute of America. Read October 16, 2026.
- FAR subpart 36.3, Two-Phase Design-Build Selection Procedures — Acquisition.gov (U.S. General Services Administration). Read October 16, 2026.
- GSAM subpart 536.71, Construction-Manager-as-Constructor Contracting — Acquisition.gov (U.S. General Services Administration). Read October 16, 2026.
Questions
Is CM at risk the same as CM/GC?
Yes, the names are used for the same method. GSA calls it construction manager as constructor. Agency construction management is different: there the CM advises the owner and holds no construction contracts.
Which delivery method is cheapest?
None is cheapest by rule. Design-bid-build gives a competitive price on a finished design but no builder input during design; the others trade some price competition for speed or earlier cost information. Your project, schedule and staff decide it.
Can public owners use design-build or CM at risk?
Federal agencies can, under FAR subpart 36.3 and GSA's construction manager as constructor rules. State and local owners need authority under their own state's law, which varies.
Related
Definition
What Is a GMP Contract in Construction?
A GMP contract caps what the owner pays: the cost of the work plus a fee, up to a ceiling. A worked example of shared savings and an overrun.
· 4 min read
Bidding
How Should an Owner Choose a General Contractor?
How a commercial owner chooses a general contractor: pick the delivery method, shortlist on qualifications, check bonding and references, then price.
· 7 min read
Preconstruction
AIA Contract Documents Explained, by Family
A plain map of AIA contract documents: the A, B, C, D, E, F and G series, the families by delivery method, and which forms you meet on a job.
· 8 min read
Pillar
The Construction Project Lifecycle: Bid to Closeout
The phases of a construction project, from planning and design to bidding, building and closeout, and what the owner, architect, GC and subs do in each.
· 7 min read
Definition
Lump Sum vs Cost-Plus: What Is the Difference?
A lump-sum contract fixes the price; a cost-plus contract pays actual cost plus a fee. Definitions, a worked comparison, and where a GMP fits.
· 3 min read
Role hub
The Owner's Guide to a Commercial Building Project
The owner's role on a commercial building project, phase by phase: delivery method, choosing the contractor, pay apps, change orders and closeout.
· 7 min read
